Welcome to the latest scoop on the Budget Beauty Blog, where we're zeroing in on the delicate dance between eyeliner and eyelash extensions.

Finding an eyeliner that complements, rather than compromises, your fluttery lash extensions can be a challenge. That's why we've meticulously researched and compiled a list of the best eyeliners that promise compatibility with your beloved extensions.

From gentle formulas to smudge-proof performance, we've got you covered. Whether you're aiming for a dramatic cat-eye or a subtle definition, our guide will help you navigate the beauty aisles with confidence.

Get ready to enhance your eyes with the perfect eyeliner picks that won't let you—or your lashes—down.

What is the best eyeliner for eyelash extensions?

The best eyeliner for eyelash extensions is typically a water-based, oil-free formula. Pencil liners are often recommended because they are less likely to interfere with the adhesive used for extensions. One highly-regarded option is the Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner, known for its gentle application and long-lasting wear. It's crucial to avoid oil-based or waterproof liquid liners, as they can weaken the glue bond and cause premature shedding of your extensions. Always look for products specifically labeled as safe for use with eyelash extensions to ensure the longevity and health of your beautiful, extended lashes.

Review Of The Best Eyeliner For Eyelash Extensions

Let’s dive into these products to find out which one is the best eyeliner for lash extensions!

bareMinerals Lash Domination Ink Liner Eyeliner

If liquid eyeliner is your number one eyeliner choice, this product will be your new hype. Its ink texture contains a well-pigmented liquid that comes off really easily through a nice fine tip to make sure you achieve that precise wing liner.

This eyeliner also benefits the eyelash extensions in a delightful way. The ink goes off softly and accurately on your lashes without affecting them thanks to its non-oil-based ingredients.

Feel confident to stay out all day smudging-free with this long-lasting eyeliner. However, you will find no difficulty to remove it at the end of the day, leaving your lashes stabilizing and glowing.

• Thing we liked
• Things we didn't like

• Precise point tip
• Easy to apply
• Easy to remove
• No smudging at all
• The tip produces bubbles which clogged easily

Marc Jacobs Highliner Gel Eye Crayon Eyeliner

Get yourself comfortable using this gel-crayon eyeliner from Marc Jacobs! Even if you are a makeup apprentice or professional, this product will enchant you with its super pigment texture varied in 12 shades and its longevity on your extended eyelash.

It is fairly effortless to work with this eyeliner as it contains a “crayon-pencil” tip that flows smoothly on your lashes while creating excellent liner that pops out your eyes.

Being one of the best eyeliner for eyelash extensions with decent staying power confirmed, this eyeliner is truly a friend to eyelash extensions indeed!

• Thing we liked
• Things we didn't like

• 12 shades available
• Long-lasting liner
• No smudging
• Creamy and pigmented ink

• The gel can dry out very fast
• Low precision in wing-liner
• Bulky packaging (sharpener included)

Kat Von D Ink Liner Eyeliner

This eyeliner from Kat Von D can change your subscription of liquid eyeliner! This hype is most well-known for its precise yet adjustable tip that can pull off any kind of liner you wish for. It produces smooth pigmented ink that won’t smudge or budge throughout the day.

Your extended lashes will surely love this eyeliner as the fine tip felt point makes the liner impossible to interfere with getting ink or pressure on your lashes. The liner stays on all day so you can rock all the time.

• Thing we liked
• Things we didn't like

• Fine brush tip
• Long-lasting matte liner
• Pigmented ink
• Easy to apply

• Fairly expensive
• Insufficient amount of ink

Soap and Glory Supercat Eyeliner

This Soap and Glory eyeliner is ensured to give you and your extended lashes a rich yet intense liner. You can be either natural with smooth fine liner or fierce with powerful and thick edges as the product is claimed to be made with a high percentage of carbon black for intense color release.

The soft fine tip of this eyeliner makes it super easy for beginners to apply while at the same time, delicately protects your eyelash extensions. Certainly one of the best eyeliner for eyelash extensions!

• Thing we liked
• Things we didn't like

• Nice fine tip
• Easy to apply
• High pigmentation

• Dry out easily once applied
• Hard to remove afterward

Bobbi Brown Longwear Gel Eyeliner

The only carefully chosen gel eyeliner on the list is certified to satisfy you and your eyelash extensions due to its ability to pull off any kind of liner without irritating your lashes. Its longevity and pigmentation during the day are truly worth the hype.

Bobbi Brown products have always been on the list of perfect products and its eyeliner is not an exception. No fading or running ink, being completely waterproof and long-lasting, this eyeliner can serve you months without quality degrading!

Consider this as one of the choices for best eyeliner for eyelash extensions!

• Thing we liked
• Things we didn't like

• High pigmentation
• Easy to apply

• Bulky packaging (brush included)
• Low-precision liner

What Eyeliner Should Be Chosen For Eyelash Extension?

Are you worried about the inability to put on eyeliner once you have your lashes extended? Don’t let them prevent you from getting more beautiful with an eyeliner. However, to protect your new fluttery friends, you need an eyeliner that is certified safe for your lash extension.

You need to consider carefully which types of eyeliner should you use together with lash extension.

Liquid Eyeliner: YES

The liquid formula of liquid eyeliner is clearly proved to be the most friendly and gentle friend to your extended lashes as you literally paint it on.

Your lash won’t be heavily affected and disturbed when being sat down upon a gentle, lightweight liquid liner.

Furthermore, removing liquid eyeliner is not too difficult and does not require any force that can sabotage your extended lashes. Just simply use micellar water or makeup removal oil to wipe away the liner excess.

Washable Eyeliner: YES

You will not want to be in the situation when your eyeliner won’t come off despite how hard you have rubbed your eyes with makeup removal. Choosing a non-washable eyeliner means that you are risking your extended eyelashes’ life.

Eyelash extension can seriously be damaged by powerful actions toward eyes and if your eyeliner is being way too unnecessarily durable, your lashes can be in trouble.

Make sure to purchase an eyeliner that still can be long-lasting but be washable at the end of the day to give your lashes a relief.

Pencil Eyeliner: NO

Pencil eyeliner can surely grant you a soft look, however, sometimes it requires such an amount of pressure to ensure you a perfect pigmented application.

In addition, oftentimes it requires you to really get in there at the root of the lashes and the tip of the pencil might simply be too firm and rough and dislodge the extensions and loosen the glue.

You might get pencil eyeliner getting all the way to the roots of the lashes, which turns out to be harmful to your extensions as the pencil tips being firm and rough can loosen up the glue and ruin your baby lashes.

For all those reasons above, you should give your pencil eyeliner a rest.

Gel Eyeliner: NO

You might be surprised by this since gel eyeliner is anybody’s friend - so easy and smooth to apply.

You assume that gel eyeliner can do no harm to your eyelash extension but you might think twice before purchasing a new gel eyeliner once you’ve got extensions on.

The problem with gel eyeliner is that it usually contains a thick formula which makes it very long-lasting but on the other hand, very hard to remove afterward.

And as I have mentioned before, beware of what might happen to your extension when your eyeliner is too durable. Gel eyeliner takes a lot of scrubbing oil to be wiped and that is surely not the thing that your extended lashes would enjoy.

Eyeliner that contains oils: ABSOLUTELY NO

Oil is the no. 1 enemy of lash extensions because it can damage the glue that the extension sits on. Finding a non-oil eyeliner is the most important factor you need to learn by heart whenever you decide to buy an eyeliner once you have your extension.

How To Apply Eyeliner With Eyelash Extension?

Tip 1: Choose what kind of your eyeliner you prefer

You would want a sharp, dramatic liner that would fierce anyone who comes close or you just want to enjoy a nice decent day with a gently friendly wing liner? Deciding what liner style you want from the start to get yourself ready for the first ink movement.

Tip 2: Start with the wing first

It can be really irritating if you start lining the inner corner first as your extension can block your vision and you can mess up easily with your eyeliner’s movement. Go outside and start off with your wing first to determine where your eyeliner has settled.

Tip 3: Leave the line going down from the wing

Slowly drag the liner down from the upward wing and move along into the inner corner, Fill in the blank and your wing is beautifully finished.

Tip: once you go into the inner corner, gently pull your lash extensions down so you can visualize your eyeliner’s movement.

Tip 4: Fixing your wing with concealer using a flat brush

Tap a small amount of concealer and gently use a flat brush to adjust your wing to be as sharp and keen as you want. And your flawless eyeliner is completed!

Final Thoughts

Having eyelash extensions can be super fun and worthy, so don’t ruin those fluttery friends by choosing the wrong eyeliner. You can have both pretty extended eyelashes and perfect eyeliner if you choose one of our top 5 best eyeliner for eyelash extensions.

Of all these five incredible eyeliners, I highly recommend you choose bareMinerals Lash Domination Ink Liner Eyeliner. With an affordable price, this eyeliner delivers all excellent features which is the best eyeliner for lash extensions.

Related Posts: